Do Canadians pay US estate tax on a Florida condo?
It is the most common question we get from Canadian owners, and the honest answer has three parts rather than one.
The treaty usually helps. The help is not automatic. And for real estate specifically, the version of the reassurance most people have heard may not be the one that applies.
## **The Question Every Canadian Snowbird Eventually Asks**
It surfaces at a dinner table in Toronto or Calgary, usually after somebody's neighbour has had a bad experience.
The facts are always similar. A Canadian couple own a condo in Naples, Sarasota or Fort Myers. They have owned it for years, they spend the winter in it, they pay the property taxes and the HOA fees without complaint, and they have never filed anything with the IRS because nothing has ever required it.
Then someone mentions that the United States taxes the estates of foreign owners, and that the threshold is sixty thousand dollars rather than the millions that apply to Americans.
That is where the worry starts, and it is a reasonable one. The threshold really is that low.
## **Why the Usual Answer Is Reassuring**
For Canadians, there is a treaty, and it is the single biggest exception to everything else written about US estate tax for foreign owners.
The IRS states plainly that the estate tax provisions are located in [Article XXIX B of the United States and Canada Income Tax Treaty](https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/estate-gift-tax-treaties-international). That is unusual. Most countries have no estate tax treaty with the United States at all, which is why generic advice written for "foreign owners" tends to be far gloomier than a Canadian's actual position.
The treaty can improve the position in more than one way. The [Instructions for Form 706-NA](https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i706na) confirm that the credit available to a nonresident estate can be affected by a treaty, and they describe a separate relief available under the 1995 Protocol: a small estate exemption where the worldwide estate of a Canadian resident decedent is not more than **\$1.2 million**.
So the reassurance has a real basis. A Canadian family is frequently in a materially better position than the headline threshold suggests, and in plenty of cases no US estate tax is ultimately payable.
That is where most conversations stop. It should not be.
## **Why Reassurance Is Not the Same as Nothing to Do**
Here is the part that catches families, and it is the whole reason this post exists.
**Treaty relief is claimed. It is not received.**
The IRS instructions are explicit. Where a return position is based on a death tax treaty or protocol, a statement has to be attached to the return saying so. For the small estate exemption specifically, the exempt assets are left off one part of the return and listed instead in an attached statement relying on the treaty.
Read what that assumes: **A return**.
There is a second detail in the same passage that families miss entirely. To work out whether the small estate exemption even applies, the exempt assets must be included in the value of the **entire gross estate, wherever located**. The test looks at the worldwide estate. A family that has never added up the Canadian house, the registered accounts and the Florida condo in one place does not actually know which side of the \$1.2 million line they are on.
And there is a point specific to this question. The small estate exemption, as the IRS describes it, applies to US securities and certain other US-situs property. Real property is not obviously inside that description. A Canadian whose US asset is a brokerage account and a Canadian whose US asset is a Florida condo may not be in the same position at all, even with identical worldwide estates.
That distinction is worth proper advice rather than an assumption, and it is the single most common place where reassurance given at a dinner table turns out not to fit the facts.
It is also a gap that a good Canadian adviser will not necessarily close. A Canadian accountant handles the Canadian return and the deemed disposition on death competently, because that is their system. The US federal position on a US-situs asset sits outside it. Families frequently have excellent advice on one side of the border and none at all on the other, without realising the two are separate questions.
## **What the Family Finds Out Later If Nobody Files**
Nothing happens for a while. That is the difficulty.
No notice arrives after the death, because nothing has been filed for the IRS to respond to. The family grieves, the Canadian estate is administered in the ordinary way, and the condo sits there apparently untouched by any of it.
It surfaces when somebody tries to move the asset. A US institution declines to release an account, or the condo sells and the proceeds are held in escrow pending an IRS clearance letter rather than paid to the heirs. At that point the family discovers that the relief they were told about had to be claimed, that the window for claiming it cleanly has passed, and that the Canadian estate cannot close while the US position is open.
If the property is then sold, a further set of rules arrives. [FIRPTA withholding](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/services/firpta) applies on the disposition, and recovering any over-withheld amount means a [US nonresident return](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/services/1040-nr). That is a second workstream discovered at the worst moment, when a buyer is already waiting.
Meanwhile the Canadian estate cannot close. An estate waiting on a US clearance stays open, which means the family carries professional costs in two countries, sometimes for years, over a position that could have been settled in the first few months.
None of this is unrecoverable. It is simply much more expensive, and much slower, than dealing with it at the start.
### **When to Bring In a Form 706-NA Specialist**
The trigger is ownership, not death.
If you are Canadian and you own US property, the useful time to understand your position is now, while it is a planning question. What the worldwide estate actually totals, whether the treaty relief is likely to apply to the assets you hold, and what your executor will need to do are all answerable in a short piece of work.
The second-best time is immediately after a death, before anything is listed or sold.
The worst time is when a buyer is waiting, which is when most families call.
Foreign Tax CPA handles [nonresident estate filings](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/services/706-na) for Canadian and other foreign owners, including treaty positions, the clearances needed before a US asset can move, and the situations where a [probate file has a foreign decedent or a foreign heir](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/realtors-probate). We work with executors in Canada and with the Canadian advisers already acting, rather than in place of them.
If you own US property and have never checked where you stand, that is a conversation worth having while it is still a choice.
## **Canadians and US Estate Tax: Frequently Asked Questions**
### Do Canadians pay US estate tax on US property?
Yes, The filing threshold for a nonresident, non-citizen decedent is far lower than the exemption available to US families. The US and Canada treaty can reduce or remove the tax in many cases, but it changes the outcome rather than removing the question.
### Does the Canada treaty exempt a Florida condo from US estate tax?
Not automatically, and real estate needs care. The IRS describes a small estate exemption under the 1995 Protocol covering US securities and certain other US-situs property where the worldwide estate is not more than \$1.2 million. Whether a particular property falls inside that relief is a question to get answered rather than assumed.
### Is the treaty relief automatic?
No. The IRS instructions require that a return position based on a death tax treaty or protocol be supported by a statement attached to the return. Relief that is never claimed is relief that was never applied.
### How is the \$1.2 million small estate threshold measured?
Against the entire gross estate wherever located, not against the US assets alone. The Canadian home and other worldwide assets count toward the test, which is why families are often surprised by which side of it they fall on.
### What happens if the family only finds out years after the death?
The position is recoverable. It is usually discovered when a sale or an account release stalls, which is the most expensive point to deal with it, and penalties and interest run from the original due date rather than from the day the family learned a requirement existed.
**Own US property and not sure where you stand?** [Start your intake form](https://MIurl.cc/d6GraDbmI) · Or call \+1 (321) 784-8329
**Foreign Tax CPA, LLC,** Tax solutions for foreign owners of US property. Phone: \+1 (321) 784-8329 · Email: admin@foreigntaxcpa.com · WhatsApp: \+1 (941) 200-1040. 174 N. Orlando Avenue, Cocoa Beach, FL 32931