Back to the blog

FIRPTA and the Closing Agent: What to Confirm Before the Wire Clears

A FIRPTA problem almost never looks like a FIRPTA problem at the start. It looks like a clean file. Contract signed, title clear, funds in escrow, closing on Thursday. Then somebody asks whether the seller is a US person, and nobody has the answer in writing. The question matters more to the closing agent than it first appears, because by the time it surfaces the money is usually already in the account and a wire is scheduled. ## **What the Closing Agent Is Actually Responsible For Under FIRPTA** Start with who the IRS says carries this. In most cases the buyer, the transferee, is the withholding agent. The IRS is direct about it: the transferee must find out whether the transferor is a foreign person, and if the transferor is foreign and the transferee fails to withhold, the transferee may be held liable for the tax. That is set out on the IRS [FIRPTA withholding](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/services/firpta) page. So the statutory liability for the tax sits with the buyer, not the closing agent. That is where most explanations stop, and it is why closing professionals sometimes assume this is not their problem. The same IRS page does not stop there. It says persons purchasing US real property interests from foreign persons, certain purchasers' agents, and settlement officers are required to withhold. Settlement officers are named. Not as a courtesy and not as a footnote. The practical position matches the text. The closing agent holds the funds, prepares the settlement statement and sends the wire. A buyer told nothing about FIRPTA will not withhold on their own initiative. Whatever the allocation of liability, the person who can stop the wrong amount leaving is the one at the settlement table. ## **When FIRPTA Seller Status Should Be Confirmed** Not on closing day. At the document stage. Seller status is a question of fact that has to be established and documented before the numbers are set, because it changes the numbers. A seller can provide a certification of non-foreign status, signed under penalties of perjury, stating that they are not a foreign person. That certification is the mechanism the rules provide, and the time to ask for it is when the contract and title documents are being assembled. Asking late creates two problems. The file is reopened to correct the figures, and the parties are told the proceeds are smaller than the settlement statement they have already seen. Neither conversation goes well on closing day. A foreign seller will sometimes raise a tax treaty at this point. Treaties can change how the gain is finally taxed on the seller's own return, but they do not generally switch off the withholding at the table, because the United States keeps the right to tax gains on US real property. The residence exception makes the timing point sharper. Where the buyer acquires the property for use as a residence and the amount realized is not more than \$300,000, withholding may not be required. The IRS sets conditions on this: the buyer or a member of their family must have definite plans to reside at the property for at least half the days it is used by anyone during each of the first two twelve month periods after the transfer, and the buyer must be an individual. The detail is on the IRS page covering [exceptions from FIRPTA withholding](https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/exceptions-from-firpta-withholding). That exception depends on the buyer's intention, which only the buyer knows. The IRS guidance says plainly that the buyer should inform the closing agent of a plan to use the property as a residence. If nobody asks, nobody is told. ## **What Happens If the Wrong FIRPTA Amount Gets Wired** Once the funds leave, the options narrow. Too little withheld and the shortfall must be recovered from a seller who may now be outside the United States, with the buyer carrying the exposure. Too much withheld and the seller's money sits with the IRS until a return is filed, which is a [Form 1040-NR refund claim](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/services/1040-nr) and a wait measured in months. Neither is a quiet problem. The first produces a liability for your buyer. The second produces an angry seller who holds you responsible for money they cannot reach. There is also a trap inside the residence exception. The IRS states that where a buyer relies on the exception and then does not reside at the property for the minimum period, the buyer is liable for the failure to withhold, unless the failure was caused by a change in circumstances that could not reasonably have been anticipated at the time of transfer. An intention recorded at closing is not a guarantee of what happens afterwards. ## **The FIRPTA Deadlines That Run After the Wire** Closing is not the end of the obligation. [Forms 8288 and 8288-A](https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-8288-a) are generally due by the 20th day after the date of transfer. This is the deadline most often missed, because the file feels finished once the wire has gone. If an application for a withholding certificate is pending at closing, the timing changes rather than disappearing. The IRS instructions set the deadline as the 20th day after the day the IRS mails the withholding certificate or the notice of denial. Planning ahead has its own clock. The IRS states that it will normally act on a withholding certificate application within 90 days of receiving a complete application, including the taxpayer identification numbers of all parties to the transaction. A certificate is not something that can be arranged in the week before closing, and a missing tax identification number is enough to stop the application being complete. ## **How Foreign Tax CPA Supports Closing Agents and Title Teams** Most of what Foreign Tax CPA does for closing professionals happens before the problem becomes one. A seller status question answered in writing while the file is open is short work. The same question the day before closing is a scramble, and the options left are fewer and worse. Where withholding does apply, [FIRPTA withholding](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/services/firpta) compliance is core work here, including determinations, the post-closing filings, and the refund position the seller will ask about afterwards. We also handle the tax identification numbers the parties need, which is frequently what delays everything else. We work alongside your file rather than taking it over. For teams carrying [probate listings with foreign heirs or a foreign decedent](https://www.foreigntaxcpa.com/realtors-probate), the same applies with an estate layered on top. If a file on your desk has a foreign seller on it now, send it before the settlement statement is final. ## **FIRPTA Closing Agent Frequently Asked Questions** ### Does the closing agent have to verify FIRPTA seller status? The IRS places the obligation to establish foreign seller status on the buyer as transferee. In practice the closing agent is the party who requests and holds the FIRPTA documentation, and the IRS names settlement officers among those required to withhold, so FIRPTA seller status verification rarely sits outside the settlement table. ### What does a FIRPTA non-foreign status certification do? A certification of non-foreign status is a statement signed under penalties of perjury that the seller is not a foreign person. It is the documented basis for not applying FIRPTA withholding at closing, which is why it belongs with the contract and title documents rather than appearing on closing day. ### When is Form 8288 due after a FIRPTA closing? FIRPTA withholding is reported on Forms 8288 and 8288-A, generally due by the 20th day after the date of transfer. The FIRPTA obligation does not end when the wire clears, and the gap between closing and that 20-day deadline is where closing files get forgotten. ### What happens if a FIRPTA withholding certificate is still pending at closing? The FIRPTA filing deadline moves rather than disappearing. The IRS instructions set it as the 20th day after the day the IRS mails the withholding certificate or the notice of denial, so a pending Form 8288-B application changes the timing without removing the obligation. ### Does the \$300,000 FIRPTA residence exception apply automatically? No. The FIRPTA residence exception depends on the buyer acquiring the property for use as a residence, meeting the IRS conditions on intended occupancy, and being an individual. The buyer must inform the closing agent of that intention, and if the buyer later does not reside there for the required period, FIRPTA liability can return to them. Talk to us about closing with a foreign seller. [**Start your intake form**](https://miurl.cc/paR3q8ZmI) Foreign Tax CPA, LLC, Tax solutions for foreign owners of US property. Phone: \+1 (321) 784-8329 · Email: admin@foreigntaxcpa.com · WhatsApp: \+1 (941) 200-1040. 174 N. Orlando Avenue, Cocoa Beach, FL 32931