Back to the blog

Your ITIN May Be Causing Your Tax Return to Be Rejected

IMPORTANT NOTICE

Your ITIN May Be Causing Your Tax Return to Be Rejected

What foreign property owners and partnership investors need to know — April 2026

Action Required If Any of the Following Apply to You:

You are a foreign (non-U.S.) owner of U.S. real estate

You are a foreign partner in a U.S. partnership or LLC

You have an ITIN but have not filed a U.S. tax return since 2021

You are selling U.S. property and do not have a current U.S. taxpayer number

Your tax preparer has told you your return was rejected or delayed

What Is an ITIN and Why Does It Matter?

An ITIN — Individual Taxpayer Identification Number — is a nine-digit number issued by the U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS). It is the tax identification number used by foreign individuals who own U.S. property, receive U.S. income, or are partners in U.S. business entities.

Your ITIN is required on every U.S. tax return you file. It is also required by the buyer's representative at the time of a real estate sale. Without a valid ITIN:

• Your U.S. tax return will be rejected by the IRS

• Any tax refund you are owed will be withheld indefinitely

• Tax credits you are entitled to will be disallowed

• A real estate closing may be delayed or complicated

• You may receive penalty notices from the IRS

Why Your Return May Be Rejected Right Now

Two significant changes are affecting foreign property owners and investors in the current (2026) filing season:

Change 1 — The IRS No Longer Accepts Placeholders

In the past, tax preparers could file returns using a placeholder number or the notation 'Applied For' when a client's ITIN was pending. The IRS has ended this practice. Returns filed without a valid, current ITIN are now rejected at the time of submission. There is no grace period.

Change 2 — Mass ITIN Expiration (December 31, 2025)

The IRS does not send a notification when your ITIN expires. If you have not used your ITIN on a U.S. federal tax return in 2022, 2023, or 2024, your ITIN expired automatically on December 31, 2025. Additionally, many older ITINs (those with middle digits 70 through 88 in the format 9XX-70-XXXX) have permanently expired under a law enacted in 2015.

This means you may have an ITIN number on file — and still face a rejection — because the number is no longer valid.

If You Are Selling U.S. Real Estate — Special Rules Apply

When a foreign person sells U.S. real property, U.S. law (known as FIRPTA) requires that a portion of the sale proceeds be withheld and sent to the IRS. This withholding — typically 15% of the sale price — is held as a deposit against any tax you may owe on the gain from the sale.

Here is why your ITIN matters critically at this stage:

• The IRS issues a document called Form 8288-A (Copy B) after your sale is processed. This is the document you must attach to your U.S. tax return to claim credit for the tax that was already withheld.

• The IRS will NOT issue this document to you if your TIN is missing from the withholding forms. Without it, you cannot claim your withholding credit, and you may not receive a refund of amounts over-withheld.

• If you do not yet have an ITIN, there is a specific IRS procedure to apply for one at the same time as your property sale is processed. This must be initiated at or before closing — not after.

Foreign Tax CPA, LLC manages this process for you. We coordinate directly with both IRS processing centers involved in FIRPTA transactions.

What You Need to Do — Step by Step

The most important action you can take is to contact us before your filing deadline or your property closing date. Here is how we help you resolve this:

1 Contact us immediately Do not wait until your closing date or tax filing deadline. ITIN applications take 7 to 11 weeks to process, and sometimes longer.

2 We will assess your ITIN status We will determine whether your ITIN is still valid, has expired, or needs to be obtained for the first time.

3 We prepare and file Form W-7 on your behalf As an IRS-authorized Certifying Acceptance Agent (CAA), we can verify your identity documents without requiring you to mail your original passport to the IRS.

4 We coordinate with the IRS on your tax filing For property sales under FIRPTA, we manage the dual-submission process to both IRS campuses (Austin and Ogden) on your behalf.

5 We file your tax return with your valid ITIN attached Once your ITIN is issued or renewed, we file your Form 1040-NR or partnership return with the correct identification number in place.

How Long Does This Take?

ITIN processing at the IRS typically takes 7 to 11 weeks when all documents are correctly prepared and submitted. Processing can take longer during the busy tax filing season (January through April) or following periods of IRS operational disruption.

This means timing is critical. We recommend contacting us as early as possible — ideally at least 12 weeks before your closing date or tax filing deadline. Do not assume that a filing extension alone will solve the problem; tax owed is still due by the original deadline even if the return is filed later.

A Note on Filing Extensions

Filing Form 4868 (individual extension) or Form 7004 (partnership extension) gives you more time to FILE your return — it does not give you more time to PAY any tax owed. Interest and penalties on unpaid tax accrue from the original due date. An extension is still valuable to avoid the late-filing penalty, but it does not resolve an ITIN issue on its own.

Frequently Asked Questions

Question Answer

I have an ITIN. Does that mean it is still valid? Not necessarily. ITINs expire if they have not been used on a U.S. federal tax return within the last three years. If you have not filed a U.S. return using your ITIN in 2022, 2023, or 2024, your ITIN expired on December 31, 2025 and must be renewed.

The IRS never told me my ITIN expired. Why? The IRS does not send a notification when an ITIN expires. You are responsible for monitoring expiration. Most clients only discover the issue when a return is rejected or a refund is withheld.

Can I just use a placeholder number and fix it later? No. The IRS no longer accepts placeholder TINs (such as 999-99-9999) on filed returns, and e-filed returns with missing or invalid TINs are rejected immediately. Your return must carry a valid ITIN before it is submitted.

What happens to my tax refund if my ITIN is expired? The IRS will hold your refund until your ITIN is renewed and your return is processed. This can delay your refund by many months.

I am selling a property. Do I need an ITIN before closing? Yes, or you must apply for one at the time of closing using a specific IRS procedure. Without a TIN, the IRS will not issue the withholding credit document (Form 8288-A, Copy B) that you need to claim your withholding on your tax return.

How long does the ITIN process take? Generally 7 to 11 weeks, but it can take longer during peak season or after IRS operational disruptions. We strongly recommend beginning the process at least 12 weeks before your filing deadline or closing date.

Can I file a tax extension while waiting for my ITIN? Yes. You can request a filing extension without an ITIN. However, any taxes owed are still due by the original deadline. An extension gives you more time to file, not more time to pay.

Contact Foreign Tax CPA, LLC

Janet Noack, CPA

Foreign Tax CPA, LLC

International Tax Compliance

FOREIGNTAXCPA.COM We specialize in:

• ITIN applications and renewals

• FIRPTA withholding compliance

• Form 1040-NR (nonresident returns)

• Partnership returns with foreign partners

• IRS notice response and representation

This document is provided for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Consult a qualified CPA for guidance specific to your situation.